About this blog Subscribe to this blog

Ideas: Please Stop Talking About Banning Private School

It's become somewhat popular among reformy types over the past couple of years to float the idea of "banning" private school and making everyone go to a public school.  (Counter-reformers have their favorite stories, too, but we'll save those for another time.) 

Picture 44Warren Buffet, Joel Klein, Michelle Rhee, Steve Barr, and most recentlyJason Kamras are those I've seen or read deliver a version of the same story (often without attributing it to Buffet, whom I understand to be its originator).  Some propose banning homeschooling, too.  Others point out that we'd have to assign kids randomly rather than by neighborhood.

I'm not sure anyone's decided what would happen to charter schools under this scenario, but it doesn't matter.  Things would get better, fast, is the point.  And indeed they might.  So too if we eliminated local school districts (as Matt Miller proposed a few years ago) or lowered any number of other structural obstacles to a better-run, more rational school system.  

But none of these things is going to happen any time soon, and I for one have gotten annoyed at this particular "thought experiment," which seems desperate and misleading.  It's desperate because its fanciful nature suggests that reformers are out of ideas; even their magic bullets are made up, now (though to be fair, I'm suspicious about the existence of "Finland," too).  It's misleading because it fails to acknowledge that, by focusing almost exclusively on the poorest neighborhoods and the lowest-performing teachers and schools, reformers have contributed to the lack of engagement among middle-class and wealthy families whose interests are going to be needed to make education better at scale. 

Anyway, please stop. Thanks.  


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

In 2001, a bill (SB 715) that would have required all public school teachers to enroll their school-aged children in a public school was introduced in the California State Senate. The measure was opposed by the California Teachers Association. http://tinyurl.com/4rteztn

I thought you were making it up.

Still, how can you criticize the man's mind-numbing,cold-blooded cynicism? In view of your own posture, I mean.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in This Week In Education are strictly those of the author and do not reflect the opinions or endorsement of Scholastic, Inc.