About this blog Subscribe to this blog

Thompson: Carmel Martin As "Candide"

MerrygoroundDuring the Fordham Institute’s recent panel discussion, Turnaround Merry-Go-Round: Is the Music Stopping?, the Department of Education’s Carmel Martin reminded me of Voltaire’s Candide.

Like Candide, Martin bravely endured a devastating critique by Fordham’s Andy Smarick of the Duncan administration’s School Improvement Grant outcomes. She countered that it is wrong to compare decades of failed turnarounds with today’s turnarounds.  Her evidence was that Secretary Duncan meets with a lot of state leaders, and those talks make him optimistic.

Martin gamely responded to critiques of NCLB-type accountability schemes, citing the political pressures that produced such flawed metrics. Finally, Martin faced the question of unintended results of data-driven accountability.  In order to boost graduation rates, systems resorted to credit recovery gimmicks and, in order to raise test scores, they adopted assessments with easier questions. So, has that not undermined the transition to more challenging instruction required by Common Core? 

Martin replied, “Again, it’s an area where I’m going to take the optimistic view instead of the pessimistic.”-JT(@drjohnthompson) Image via.           

TV: Oprah Network Features NOLA Turnaround Story

Coming in March, Oprah Winfrey's OWN network is going to start airing Blackboard Wars, the six-part story of the attempt to turn around NOLA's McDonogh High School. 

image from 1.bp.blogspot.comFrom the announcement:  "The Discovery Studios-produced docu-series centers on the dramatic transformation of New Orleans’ John McDonogh High School, one of the most dangerous and under-performing high schools in the country, where more than half of its students fail to graduate. The show, which will premiere in March, will go behind the scenes with education maverick Steve Barr and no-nonsense principal Dr. Marvin Thompson as they embark on an unpredictable mission to reinvent and revive the struggling school."

From another writeup:  "Blackboard Wars" examines the dramatic transformation of John McDonogh High School in New Orleans, which had a 54% dropout rate before the changes were put in place. “Education maverick” Steve Barr and “no-nonsense principal” Marvin Thompson have increased the attendance rate to around 80%, and they hope that in a few years, the graduation rate will skyrocket to 90%. The students at this school "feel disenfranchised," according to Thompson, who believes that treating each child differently creates a greater chance of success. The population also includes 19-, 20-, and 21-year-old sophomores, so the teachers have their work cut out for them." (San Jose TV

Apparently it was originally called Treme High

Thompson: A Win-Win Approach to School Turnarounds

The vast majority of school turnarounds use the drastic methods encouraged by the Duncan Administration's School Improvement Grant experiment. 

Teachplus

The Hechinger Ed's "Giving Teachers More Power Helps in Turnaround of Boston Schools" links to ASCD's evidence why those punitive methods are unlikely to work.  For instance, Massachusetts turnarounds that used more generic professional development and teacher support, and struggled to create a safe school environments, produced few gains.

But, Hechinger reports that Boston, in collaboration with Teach Plus, recruited proven teachers to lead the turnaround of six schools.  Boston model provided intensive teacher professional development over the summer, and health and wellness services for students. By the second year, these schools were producing double digit gains in math and reading.  The Boston method thus follows the original turnaround vision of "the Readiness Triangle," In contrast to more typical turnarounds, it does not skip "Readiness to Teach" and "Readiness to Learn." 

 The Boston/Teach Plus model could thus rescue SIG from its tendency to take teacher-bashing shortcuts, as it helps descalate our educational civil war.-JT(@drjohnthompson) Image via.

Morning Video: Fordham Panel On Turnarounds

Carmel Ninety-minute video of Monday's panel featuring Carmel Martin, Checker Finn, Andy Smarick, Jean-Claude Brizard (here)

Thompson: A SIG Success Story is Audited

DouglassOrdinarily, Oklahoma City’s Douglass High School would be proclaimed as a School Improvement Grant (SIG) success story: 

In 2012, it posted double-digit increases in four subjects, single-digit gains in four, and declines in only three tests.  After replacing 75% of its faculty, investing heavily in after-school tutoring and intersession remediation, and implementing its SIG "academic intervention plan," the high school earned a “C” on Oklahoma’s tough new report card.  It earned “A’s” for overall student growth, its graduation rate, advanced coursework, and “overall school improvement.”  

Douglass, however, is being investigated for awarding credits to students who have not earned them.  Now, the Daily Oklahoman's Carrie Coppernoll, in Douglass Transcript Finds Spur Call for Wider Auditing, reports that less than 20% of Douglass’ seniors are on track to graduate. To ameliorate the harm to its seniors, Douglass has no short-term option but to double-down on the full array of “credit recovery” shortcuts that got the school in the mess by “passing students on.” The lastest twist, ironically, grows out the Oklahoma Gazette's Freedom of Information request.  Jerry Bohnen, in "A Tale of Email," confirms that the former principal changed grades.  The district explains that those grade-changes would not have been appropriate under its policies, but they may have been consistent with SIG standards.-JT(@drjohnthompson) Image via.    

 

Update: Goings-On At Green Dot

ScreenHunter_07 Nov. 26 22.37So there was a handful of Green Dot-related news that came out yesterday, including (a) word from USDE that its Race to the Top application had made it to the final 61 after the initial round of reviews, (b) news from Green Dot founder Steve Barr that Green Dot NYC (or whatever it's officially called now) received a "fat" A grade from the NYC DOE (phat?), and (c) word via a Green Dot press release and LA Daily News story that Barr had resigned from the Green Dot board on which he's remained all these years since he and Green Dot split.  (LA Daily News, KPCC).

I'm not really sure of the significance, if any, to the resignation, given that Barr has moved on to a new venture, Future Is Now, which is focused on NOLA.  The Green Dot NYC school has been transferred over to FIN.  Perhaps there was some sort of flare-up, though Barr says that he just has too many other monthly board obligations. Perhaps the press release was an indication of the remaining ill will Green Dot CEO Marco Petruzzi feels towards Barr, though Petruzzi says it was just SOP.  Perhaps I'm just making a mountain out of a molehill.

Previous posts:  Green Dot & Steve Barr Finalize Their "Divorce"The Book I *Should* Have WrittenBack To Locke HighUnsolved Mysteries Of Locke High & Green Dot

Morning Video: "Frontline" Explores Child Poverty

Watch Poor Kids on PBS. See more from FRONTLINE.

Last night on Frontline, PBS explored the spread of child poverty.

SIG: A Disappointing But Completely Predictable Reaction From Smarick

image from www.scribbleoneverything.comResearcher Bryan Hassel has written a bracing (for policy wonks) response to yesterday's "SIG-failed-I-told-you-so" post from former New Jersey state education official Andy Smarick (The disappointing but completely predictable results from SIG).

In his rebuttal, Hassel questions Smarick's contention that SIG has failed and shreds Smarick's notion that starting new schools is a viable way to go:  

"There’s no evidence that new school creation is demonstrably better as an overall strategy than turnarounds... To replace the 5,000 worst schools, we’d need 10,000 high-quality new schools b/c they tend to be smaller."

Read the full post below.  

Continue reading "SIG: A Disappointing But Completely Predictable Reaction From Smarick" »

Five Best Blogs: School Reform's Inner-City Problem

Images3 (1)Arthur Levine: The Suburban Education Gap - WSJ.com ow.ly/fjDfX via @Wonkbook 

Joel Klein: We Need a Bar Exam for Educators ow.ly/1Pzhur 

How online ed is going to do to the music industry what Napster did to music Clay Shirky ow.ly/fkrJh 

Cato Unbound » Blog Archive » Why Online Education Works ow.ly/fkrI3 

New twist on cyberbullying: Anonymous vigilantes defend depressed teen, expose tormentors via Jezebel ow.ly/fjBPQ @emilybazelon

Tech Groups Offer Lame-Duck Wish Lists -NJournal ow.ly/fkrFo There's an ed reform version of this out there, somewhere

Book about poverty wins National Book Award CJRow.ly/fjBra 

Bruno: Why Do African-American Voters Support Charter Schools?

3075157040_6b6ac4af3e_mThese days it's popular to attribute electoral outcomes to influential "special interests", and certainly powerful individuals and groups can affect election results. Still, "special interests" can only get you so far in explaining democratic fortunes; voters aren't just blank slates upon which the rich and powerful can project their own preferences.

So consider me skeptical that strong African American support for a pro-charter school initiative in Georgia is best explained by "out-of-state money" (Valerie Strauss) or opponents being "drowned out" by President Obama (Jim Galloway). I'm totally prepared to believe that big money and popular leaders can change the way people vote, but by all accounts the move to make charter authorization easier was favored by a large majority of African American voters. 

Had the results been closer it might make sense to attribute the results to the persuadability - or gullibility - of a few marginal voters. If accounts of 2-1 support among black voters are accurate, however, there is probably more than enough informed and "authentic" support for charter schools in African American communities to deserve to be taken seriously.

The charter school movement has definitely made for some awkward political alliances (and enemies), but that makes it all the more necessary for opponents of charter schools to engage with the very real concerns charter proponents hope to address. Yes, many black leaders are justifiably worried about school resegregation, but many black parents conspicuously are not (at least to the same degree).  

What are black parents worried about? I'm not really sure and neither, apparently, are many charter school opponents. - PB (@MrPABruno) (image source)

Thompson: The Scandal At Douglass High School (& Beyond)

The theologian Reinhold Niebuhr famously asked how it is possible to be “a moral man in an immoral society.”  Oklahoma City is enduring a scandal that encapsulates the paradoxes of being a moral educator in our education system.  When using the word, “system,” I do not mean the OKCPS.  I mean our national system of data-driven “reform.” 

ScreenHunter_05 Nov. 04 09.01A respected principal, Dr. Brian Staples, was removed from his post at a SIG Transformation School, Douglass High School, and he was referred to the district attorney for irregularities in grade and attendance data. I have always found Staples to be an honorable man.   I also have experienced the normative, non-stop pressure to inflate accountability numbers. So, I doubt he was doing much (or anything) different than what he was previously praised for

In my experience, the individuals who pressured us to play games with statistics have always believed that they were morally correct and they have done so while implementing “research-based” best practices peddled by consultants and politicians.  And, while attendance soared to unbelievable levels under Staples, all of our district’s 90% low income, 90% minority high schools claimed identical miracles

I have remained silent on the controversy, but then I saw this video by drama teacher, Tinasha LaRaye’ Williams in support of Staples.  She and I are on opposite sides of the reform wars, but we agree that Staples was brought down while implementing the methods that he was taught at “countless” hours of professional development training and policy workshops.

Continue reading "Thompson: The Scandal At Douglass High School (& Beyond)" »

Bruno: Let's Improve the Supply of Good Schools

71575328_808dddd4e7I've already argued that our teacher quality problems are probably not caused by inadequate demand for excellent teachers, but is there inadequate demand for high quality schools?  

Bill Jackson thinks so and argues that if given better information and different incentives, parents will demand - and therefore obtain - better schools for their kids.

Maybe, maybe not.

Continue reading "Bruno: Let's Improve the Supply of Good Schools" »

Foundations: What To Think About C4TE's Collapse?

Screen shot 2012-10-22 at 12.50.26 PMReform critics reacted gleefully last week to the news that Communities for Teaching Excellence, the Gates-funded advocacy effort in support of its teacher quality initiative, was being de-funded (LAT, LA Daily News), a reaction that was  predictable but sort of sad and short-sighted.  

Why so?  First and foremost, the outcome explodes notion that reform foundations like Gates are all-powerful, which is obviously untrue but is a myth that seems convenient to repeat. Can't be all-powerful and occasionally ineffective at the same time. It's also a reflection of the reality that advocacy groups have proliferated as much as C4TE has failed.  So if reform critics want to call the creation of tons of advocacy groups a success, then fine go ahead.  

Last but not least, trashing the efforts of folks like Yolie Flores, the former LAUSD board member (pictured) who took on the task and has dedicated her career to making schools better for poor kids, seems inappropriate coming from mostly white liberals sitting in front of computers or giving speeches.  You can read more about Flores in the LA Weekly and Scholastic Administrator (who sponsors this site), and a blog post of mine about her disagreement with LAUSD and Deasy over the changes to PSC ( John Deasy's Mystifying Labor Deal).

One last thing: a couple of people have written me suggesting that the downfall of this latest effort was comparable to the failure of EDIN'08, a comparison I get but would quibble with.  Yes, advocacy is a dicey business and folks bigger and better funded than Gates have spent scads of money in other arenas and walked away without much to show for it. The highs and lows are higher in advocacy than they are in policy and program worlds.  But I don't believe that EDIN'08 was such a big failure as conventional wisdom would have it.  And, an important difference to me is that EDIN'08 was organized around a national campaign, the presidential elections, whereas the Gates teacher quality advocacy effort was focused on the individual Gates districts without any substantial national component. 

Morning Video: Tampa Student Spotlights School Violence

Eighth-grader De'Qonton Davis and his classmates set out to investigate how violence affect students' ability to learn. From the PBS NewsHour last week - to tide you over until I can get a full embed copy of the Duncan speech.

Thompson: The Story Behind Sharpstown High (& "Apollo 20")

PBS Frontline's Dropout Nation reported that Houston Superintendent Terry Grier had just been on the job for a few monthswhen he heard that four of the district's high schools were failing.  He heard about Roland Fryer’s ideas on school improvement and got in touch with him. Frontline reported that, "After a long phone conversation, Grier gathered a team and headed to Boston to hammer out a plan." It did not report on any effort by Grier to look into evidence for Fryer's hypothesis. 

FRONTLINE-DropoutNation-640

Eventually, Grier gambled $61 million on his "Apollo 20" reforms. The first year he spent $6 million replacing 310  teachers and the principals of nine schools.  The school featured by PBS, Sharpstown, was not one of the worst of the Apollo 20 high schools, but 39 of the school's 78 teachers were replaced.  Based on Frontline and other coverage, however, it appears that the school benefitted from some of the best of the administrative hires. None of my complaints with Grier's quick-triggered judgment should be taken as a criticism of Sharpstowns' dedicated educators.

Grier still maintains his facile claim about the toughest schools - that we "know what to do with them."  But, his administrators at Sharpstown openly acknowledged their inability to overcome the worst legacies of trauma and generational poverty.  While Grier's spin was consistent with the cherry-picking of Roland Fryer in featuring the experiment's successes, the school administrators' candor was consistent with the data buried in the tables of Fryer's evaluation of Apollo 20. And, as PBS reported, the second year academic results were even more modest.

Continue reading "Thompson: The Story Behind Sharpstown High (& "Apollo 20")" »

Thompson: The Promise of "Clustering" in Scaling Up Reform

MassinsightMass Insight's In The Zone offered a thoughtful response to “Common and Uncommon Ground,” a guest post at Rick Hess Straight Up by Neerav Kingsland and me. It also previewed its new report on the potential of “clustering” in order to scale up school improvement.  Mass Insight argues for:

A “Smart District” of the future, focusing on changing systems and structures so as to give schools more power to focus on the classroom level. Districts would create clusters of high schools and their feeder schools, bringing in Lead Partners to cover administrative and operational support for these clusters, and allowing central office to monitor performance, set standards, and serve as the go-between for federal and state agencies.

Clustering, I believe, is a necessary but not a sufficient condition for systemic reform.  Until we hold clusters of school accountable, charters will remain free to focus on relatively easier-to-educate low income students and dump the most traumatized children on neighborhood schools.  Clustering, alone, will not force reformers to heed the research of the Consortium for Chicago School Research and Paul Tough which explains the additional challenge of improving schools with the most intense concentrations of extreme poverty. But, it could slow the “creaming” of more motivated students that has damaged neighborhood schools.

Continue reading "Thompson: The Promise of "Clustering" in Scaling Up Reform" »

Morning Video: Rescuing - And Disappearing - Students In Houston


Last night's PBS Frontline took a look at one of Houston's Apollo 20 schools, where they're trying to lower the dropout rate -- even if it means having at risk students move in (or saying that no-shows have moved back to Mexico).

Chicago: Nobody Wins Until (White) Parents Trust Schools

Michelle Rhee is calling the Chicago contract a "missed opportunity," and indeed it was a bungled job in many regards.  However, it's worth remembering that StudentsFirst never liked SB7, the deal underlying this contract, which was agreed to before SF got to Illinois.    And this Sun Times breakdown notes that outside reform groups weren't as influential as they might have expected given their role in SB7. Boo hoo for them.

image from scholasticadministrator.typepad.comCatalyst notes several union wins as well -- a three year contract, a minimum role for student achievement in teacher evaluations. This WSJ article also notes that Emanuel didn't get nearly as much as Denver or DC did in their recent negotiations.  But NCTQ is taking a more balanced view, describing it as "generally moving the district in the right direction" thanks to the longer day and year and the evaluation pieces. Click below for their breakdown.

And as I did in a previous post on my Chicago blog (Stupid Strike), NCTQ also notes that school closings and budget issues may have more to do with whether Chicago improves than the contract provisions.     

This is the issue that folks only now seem to be waking up to -- that Chicago is going to have to continue to downsize unless it makes its schools good enough for white, college educated parents in particular to stay in town and trust their kids to Chicago schools.  Very roughly speaking, only about one of three white Chicago families sends its kids to CPS.

At the end, CTU head Karen Klein  Lewis seemed to be clear about this as well: "We couldn’t solve all the problems of the world with one contract, and that it was time to suspend the strike."

Continue reading "Chicago: Nobody Wins Until (White) Parents Trust Schools" »

Thompson: Welcoming The "New" Kevin Carey

Tumblr_m7tslnBzmB1qa0uujo1_500The 1990s was a time when the entire New Deal/Fair Deal/Great Society approach to social justice was reappraised.  Digital breakthroughs seemed to promise data-driven solutions to economic and social problems. During the Clinton boom years, some speculated that computer systems could be more accurate than doctors in diagnosing illnesses. Others believed that they even made economic cycles a thing of the past. 

Since 2001, Kevin Carey has exemplified that era's commitment to accountability-driven school reform.  He argued that inequitable schools were the result of "a basic ethical failing." In 2004, he even  claimed that value-added evaluations were a "verifiable" way of improving teacher quality in low-performing schools. 

But times have changed, and for that reason, Carey's Education Sector report, "Some Assembly Required: Building a Better Accountability System for California," is great news. It is a joy to welcome Carey to the old-fashioned data-informed approach to school improvement.  Even better, Carey explains his kinder, gentler approach to accountability with perceptive observations that have previously been made by Deborah Meier and Richard Rothstein. 

Continue reading "Thompson: Welcoming The "New" Kevin Carey" »

Five Best Blogs: Detroit Rock City

196257_701322621845_5659639_nRandi Weingarten Heads To Detroit, Aims To Force Contract Negotiations For Teachers ow.ly/cyufA#5bb

From May: Former US News education editor @bwildavsky reflects on errors and missteps in his higher ed book ow.ly/cyn3Y #5bb

Five Reasons You Should (or Shouldn’t) Share [Education] Stories With Sources ow.ly/cyhBK@edwrriters #5bb

Last week's [mediocre] Breaking Bad featured an abandoned Albuquerque high school ow.ly/cygR3

What Effect Will $15M Penn Foundation Grant Have on Philadelphia’s Schools? – Nonprofit Quarterly http://ow.ly/cyb2q  #5bb From 07/06

In Chicago, longer school day for students, but not for teachers – Schools of Thought - http://CNN.com  Blogs http://ow.ly/cy8yr  #5bb

LAUSD social media survey is out http://ow.ly/cy7lp  but i can't seem to find the raw results just the presser

Reform: The Book I *Should* Have Written

A little more than a year since the publication of my book about the conversion and attempted turnaround at Locke High School, I remain proud of the work -- and heartened about the good news that continues to come out of the school and Barr's new endeavors -- but also clear about some mistakes I made:

image from ecx.images-amazon.com1 -- The book title should have been shortened, or at least reversed -- Saints, Saviors, and Stray Dogs.  The stray dogs represented the poverty and neglect experienced by the school over the years, and did indeed wander onto campus now and then, but the book wasn't really about poverty and neglect (and the title choice was confusing and troubling to some of the school community).

2 - The book should have included at least a chapter or two more about Steve Barr, founder of Green Dot and mastermind behind the Locke conversion.  I was overly determined not to focus on him.  But limiting his presence in the book to three chapters was a substantive mistake (considering his role at Locke and nationally), a narrative one (given readers' need to have a main character), and a commercial mistake, too (given Barr's prominence). That blue inset image of the kid graduating should have been him.

3 -- It was already clear by the time I wrapped up my reporting that Locke was a lot better than it had been in the past, and the book should have made a stronger, clearer argument that broken schools like Locke can be substantially improved (if not miraculously fixed) rather than attempting to be a neutral or uncertain description of events.  Ironic that I, a blogger who trades in commentary and understands readers' needs to be challenged by strong views, held back from making a strong and clear argument in the book.  

 

Morning Video: Whatever Happened To Antipoverty Programs?

During his talk with Bill Moyers from Friday, Peter Edelman criticizes pre-Clinton welfare, explains how welfare has been stripped down to little more than Food Stamps in many states, and defends Obama's record funding antipoverty program:

Video above, transcript here. Previous posts: Will Reformers Ever Broaden Their Agenda?Pay No Attention To The Nation's Child Poverty Rate Poverty Is Back!,  Bruno: Both Sides Mis-Calculate On "Out-Of School" FactorsLet's Not Talk About 43M Poor People.

Five Best Blogs: The Education Twins (aka "Obamney," "Rombama")

Fahrenheit-451-book-cover-640x1058

Marc Tucker disagrees with Jay Mathews, imagines how the Obamney twins wld answer his questions ow.ly/bqx8B

New GAO report on bullying recommends ED and HHS provide more, better information about victims and remediesow.ly/bqXRF 

It's the ability to respond when things go wrong (not prevent mishaps) that marks excellence, reports Atul Gawandeow.ly/bqWNc 

RiShawn Biddle sucks up to @arotherham and @StudentsFirstHQ re CA primaries ow.ly/bqWq3

Banning soda isn't easy -- just as any school administrator or Mike Bloomberg, whom Kinsley dissects ow.ly/bqW7P

Five years since its official launch @dfer says it's helped raise/direct $31M for pro-reform Dems ow.ly/bqDRA

NYC Charter school rally brings out deep tensions within the sector @gothamschools ow.ly/bqAvk 

Reformers aren't evil geniuses, just naive do-gooders, says SOSer @garyrubinstein tch4.us/h4T 

Charts: Charter Laws Not Just About Cap Lifting Any More

image from www.publiccharters.org
More than 20 states have changed their charter laws since 2011 -- the roughly half of them around the much-needed issues of accountability and authorization. Via NAPC.

Thompson: One Teacher's Year-End SIG Exhaustion

image from scholasticadministrator.typepad.comOklahoma Centennial High School's Lynn Green embodies the essential quality for relating to teenagers - honesty.  Mr. Green's humor also is legendary.  Even as students grown at his puns, they praise his dedication. In "I Hit the Wall," Green candidly explains that near the end of the year at a school undergoing transformation, he was "emotionally and physically tapped out.  ...  So I took a Sick Leave day and stayed home."  He slept 12 hours straight, ate a bowl of cereal and then went back to sleep. Mr. Green sat in his reading chair and read for 4 hours.  But, he then went to the library for the student chess club that he sponsors.  After reading some more, the veteran teacher readied himself for rekindling his students' energy and taking advantage of the few remaining class periods.   His post-test lessons sound like they were great.- JT (@drjohnthompson) image via. 

Think Tanks: Hijacking The Education Sector*

145000-tomtom-medium_originalSomewhat lost in last week's news about John Chubb withdrawing from the Romney advisory team (here) was the news that EdSector's higher ed team was leaving for New America. Kevin Carey et al will be formally announced sometime this week.  No word yet on whether they'll be taking The Quick And The Ed with them (unlikely, given that Chubb has already started posting on the think tank's group blog).

Think tanks evolve over time, and are shaped by their boards and leaders, but I can't think of another example where a think tank has been transformed so quickly in such a short period of time. Former US News education reporter Tom Toch and moderate Democrat Andy Rotherham co-founded the quasi-journalistic think tank not so long ago, and another journalist, former LA Times writer R.L. Colvin, succeeded them.  Now Macke Raymond and John Chubb are in control.   Sort of amazing.  

Not that there are enough right-leaning education think tanks out there, compared to the masses of left-leaning ones. But I'd have never thought that the right would build its forces this way, or that the messy departures of Rotherham and Toch would allow the board to move so far to the right. Then again, why build a new think tank when you can hijack an existing one?

*UPDATED:  Just in time, New America sent out the announcement below.

Continue reading "Think Tanks: Hijacking The Education Sector*" »

Battlegrounds: Don't Forget New Jersey

There's StudentsFirst's partnership with state education reform advocates, and bipartisan support for measures like ending seniority-based layoffs that are strongly opposed by teachers unions (N.J. Democrats must step up on education reform). Vouchers in the air. ALEC sponsorship. Cami Anderson.  Chris Christie and his ALEC bills.  Cory Booker.  Derrell Bradford (2010 profile here).  There was a big AFC conference last week (next time, not cross-scheduled with NSVF, please). Powerpoints here. Speeches here.  Jindal's vouchers and tax rebates here (not NJ, obv, but he was at AFC).  

AM News: Renaming 24 Schools To Win SIG Millions

News image

For 24 Schools Getting New Start, 24 New Names NYT: Two dozen public schools are being renamed as part of New York City’s strategy to qualify for nearly $60 million in federal grants to help the so-called struggling schools get fresh starts.

Test Errors Draw New Criticism WSJ: A top New York state education official acknowledged Wednesday that the mounting number of errors found on this year's math and English tests has eroded public trust in the statewide exams.

LA Unified approves college prep requirements for all students SCPR:  Next year’s high school freshmen will have to take every class required to meet the minimum application standards for the University of California and Cal State systems. 

 Tennessee Tech policy violated First Amendment USAT: A federal appeals court ruled that Tennessee Tech violated the First Amendment in a case involving religious beliefs.

Unions, parents blast school austerity plans Philadelphia Inquirer: A coalition led by parent groups and Philadelphia school employee unions Wednesday blasted the district’s proposal to make drastic cuts and structural changes.

Where the Teachers Union and District Love Each Other VOSD:  If both the district and its teachers in San Diego are serious about repairing the relationship, then Poway is as good a place as any for them to study.

MORE NEWS ITEMS INSIDE

Continue reading "AM News: Renaming 24 Schools To Win SIG Millions" »

Update: What Gail Collins Gets Wrong About NCLB

School-clock(1)A couple of folks didn't like it much when, using that Twitter thing, I attempted to rain on their parade of passing around Gail Collins' recent column (A Very Pricey Pineapple).  The column makes the case that education is being privatized, and that Pearson in particular and in general is taking over, and that NCLB is the cause of it all.  Collins writes:  

"No Child Left Behind has created a system of public-funded charter schools, a growing number of which are run by for-profit companies... An American child could go to a public school run by Pearson, studying from books produced by Pearson, while his or her progress is evaluated by Pearson standardized tests."

Where to start?  Well, most charters aren't run by for-profit companies, so that's pretty much a red herring.  NCLB didn't invent or have any real direct impact on creating more charters (charter funding preceded NCLB and there were very few charter conversions).  The transfer provision was used very little.  Far as I know, Pearson does not yet run any charter schools.  

Sure, NCLB was good for testing companies because it required annual tests for reading and math instead of the periodic  ones of the past.  But this isn't news, really.  It isn't even new anymore.  Collins is trying to gin up outrage like so many others are.  But my feeling is that outrage should be reserved for truly outrageous situations.  Of which there are many.  But not this one.  

Bruno: Hidden Ripple Effects From School Closures

29cc29947af077712045bc26e4f01eabThe decision by the Missouri Board of Education to shut down the charter schools in the state run by Imagine Schools, Inc. is obviously going to be rough for the students currently enrolled at the six affected sites. If anything, though, the article understates the breadth of the problem by focusing on the fact that "[m]ore than 3,500 students will be displaced." 

That's because while school switches are typically most difficult for the students doing the switching, it can also be a challenge for the receiving school. This is especially true if the school invests heavily in establishing standard academic expectations, behavioral norms, or a sense of community. Such investments can be immensely helpful in promoting student success and maximizing instructional time, but they are also undermined by the arrival of new students to whom the standards and expectations may be entirely new. After all, much of the point of establishing school-wide culture - or even a classroom culture - is to avoid having to continuously dedicate time to creating it from scratch.

I've sometimes wondered if closing schools shouldn't be phased out in much the same way that new schools are often phased in, so that at least some students are able to finish their careers at a school before making the transition to a new site. I don't know enough to know how feasible that would be - I can see that money and staff morale could both be a problem - but if the accountability movement sustains its momentum or if district budgets are further strained, school closures are going to continue to disrupt many, many students' lives. - PB (@MrPABruno) (image source)

SIG: Three SIG Stories To Help Make It Through Monday

ScreenHunter_04 Apr. 16 10.59The wait is over.  Those Hechinger/EWA / EdWeek feature stories I told you about a couple of weeks ago are finally out:

What’s the payoff for $4.6 billion in School Improvement Grants?

Federal teacher evaluation requirement has wide impact

Haven't read them yet, hoping there's lots of new and interesting stuff in there.  Let me know?

Quotes: "It's Just Not Going To Happen"

Quotes2We know that not every single one of these schools is going to succeed... It’s just not going to happen. -- SIG guru Jason Snyder via Emily Richmond

Video: Latino Anger At Metal Detectors At Tucson Board Meetings

This picture of little boy in Batman t-shirt getting screened has gone viral, according to CNN. Last spring, students disrupted a board meeting by handcuffing themselves to board members' chairs.

Audio: Turnaround Czar Talks Transformation, MOUs

At this past weekend's SIG conference in Chicago, Jason Snyder talked about where the SIG program is and where it heads next, mentioned that MOUs between districts and unions seem to be a interesting way to get dramatic improvements done, and generally made the whole program seem like an earnest and generally well-run endeavor.  Then again, I was barely awake since it was 9 am.  Here's some audio for you to pore over, courtesy of the good folks at EWA: 

Snyder Knowles MP3

There's also a PowerPoint presentation that I'll try and get and post here, too. Note that my audio edit is very rough -- that's EWA head Caroline Hendrie speaking at the start, and the second voice is UofC's Tim Knowles (wearing a black turtleneck, bien sur).  Snyder doesn't always talk into the microphone so you'll have to deal with that.  

 

Update: Back To Locke High School

image from www.greendot.org

It's been a long time since Locke High School has been in the news (see this June 2011 LA Times piece) but it still seems relevant to me.  Before the parent trigger, there was the teacher trigger that was used to wrest Locke away from LAUSD and UTLA.  Before SIG, there was NCLB restructuring that allowed Green Dot to restaff the school. Before newTLA and the Gates charter-district collaboration initiative, there was AMU, the union of charter teachers (the topic of a WSJ opinion piece just this week).  And before Michelle Rhee and Jonah Edelman and Ben Austin, there was Steve Barr (who's opening a new school in New Orleans next year.) 

In any case, I had  an hour to walk around the campus a couple of weeks ago before heading to the airport but that was enough time to get a quick sense of things and I thought some of you might be interested.  

Continue reading "Update: Back To Locke High School" »

Bruno: When Is A Charter Not A Charter?

ASCENDThe Oakland Unified School District has just granted two elementary schools permission to convert to what they're calling "partnership schools": quasi-charters, essentially, that will continue to pay for and participate in many of the district's programs, but will also have site-level autonomy in terms of staffing and curriculum.

It's a little bit difficult to discern how satisfied the various parties are with the arrangement, which is actually a compromise between the district (which had rejected a previous charter conversion proposal) and the schools (which had appealed the decision to the more charter-friendly county). Superintendent Tony Smith is putting a positive spin on the "partnership" model, but at least some members of the school board are saying the "partnership" model was just the least-bad option available to them.

Click below for my thoughts on the situation.

Continue reading "Bruno: When Is A Charter Not A Charter?" »

Books: School Integration, Revisited

ScreenHunter_18 Mar. 05 23.53

I'm not particularly interested in school integration as an end unto itself (or unreasonably hopeful that we're going to have integrated schools anytime soon), but the potential for school integration to help increase achievement levels is pretty compelling and findings like the ones released by the USDE about disproportionate treatment of black kids in urban school systems makes the topic all the more worth revisiting.

Tomorrow in Washington, a trio of institutions (TCF, Fordham, and Howard University) is hosting an event on the future of integration and the release of new work by the indefatigable Rick Kahlenberg showing that at least 80 school districts serving 4 million kids have adopted measures to promote integration that fall within current law. The event is Wednesday at noon, National Press Club. Contact [email protected] to RSVP.

Included among Kahlenberg's example will likely be some of the handful of mixed-income, heterogenous charter schools like DSST, Capitol City, and Community Roots that I've been spending time at since last year.  I visited Larchmont and Citizens of the World last week in LA. It's a complicated, difficult-to-pull-off approach, fraught with practical and political challenges (as well as some obvious advantages over the typical neighborhood school). I'm interested to see what Kahlenberg has to say.

Bruno: Good News Bad For Our Narratives

Argument-cartoonOver at The Daily Howler, Bob Somerby has been on a tear recently pointing out that pundits of all kinds seem to be stubbornly indifferent to good education news. He emphasizes the shrinking achievement gap between black students and white students on the NAEP as something you rarely see mentioned, and I'd add that to the growing pile of good-but-largely-ignored news that includes rising achievement for disadvantaged groups generally and improving school safety.  Bob thinks we can chalk up this news blackout to the fact that commentators have sorted themselves into "tribes", each of which dislikes the other too much to risk inadvertently crediting them with an accomplishment.  I think there's definitely a lot to that explanation, but that there's also a real fear on both sides of undermining their preferred narrative.  My sense is that "reformers" don't want to talk about the good news because then they'd have to acknowledge that these positive trends mostly began prior to their favorite reforms. This would undermine the narrative that the "status quo" of salary schedules and tenure is an insurmountable obstacle to progress. At the same time, I think the anti-reform crowd is reluctant to discuss the good news because it has continued in the "corporate reform" era. This, in turn, makes the repeal of NCLB-type reforms seem that much less urgent. Whatever the explanation, however, the end result seems to be that we mostly hear about how bad our educational institutions are despite the fact that these same institutions are not only improving, but are arguably the best they've ever been. - PB (@MrPABruno) (Image source)

Fixing Broken Schools: The "Don't Mess With Us" Challenge

ScreenHunter_03 May. 03 21.37
At nearly every school, no matter how broken it may be over all, there are pockets of teachers, parents and kids who are doing good things -- a program, a department, a classroom, an activity.  What reformers have slowly come to realize -- this is from a Bill Gates talk in 2008 -- is that these pockets of promise represent both an opportunity and a challenge:  how to make things better over all without steamrolling (or being steamrolled by) pockets of excellence?   

“The problem we tend to run into is that the most influential and well-educated people either have their kids in private schools, or they have their kids in an enclave inside the high school that are called honor’s courses, where the teaching is pretty decent and so, if we go to a school and say, let’s change things here, they say, no way, you’re going to mess our little enclave up. All the kids go through the same front door, but really it’s a separate school inside there that’s allowing us not to be part of that insanity, and so don’t mess with the thing that works well for us. And I do think, if you want to stand up to some of the practices that are not focused on the needs of the students, you need a broad set of parents. I think we’re very weak on this point.”

I'm usually more than happy to criticize the Gates Foundation's efforts and approach, but I see this as a pretty honest, reflective assessment of a challenge that reformers are still coming to terms with. 

Bruno: Charter Proponents Vs. The Charter Effect

RedTapeMatt Di Carlo has a great post over at the Shanker Blog explaining why we shouldn't think about charter schools as a monolithic educational intervention given their considerable diversity. As he says, studies seem to indicate that "schools’ effects on test scores may vary less by what they are (e.g., charter versus regular public school) than by what they do (e.g., specific policies and practices)."  So we should try to identify what characteristics of the best charter schools make them effective so that those interventions can be provided to as many students as possible.

That all sounds right, but I think it's worth stepping back here and remembering that, while it's true that charter schools vary dramatically in terms of how they operate, for a lot of charter school proponents it is precisely what charter schools have in common that is supposed to make them superior alternatives to traditional district schools.

Continue reading "Bruno: Charter Proponents Vs. The Charter Effect" »

Update: TUDA Participation* Should Be A Waiver Prerequisite

#nclbwaivers     Last week I told you that there were 18 districts that were big enough to participate in the NAEP TUDA program if Congress allocated funding for an expansion (and the districts agreed or could be shamed into participating).  Well here's the list of districts that meet the size requirements:   

Classroomchaos reblogged literatureandeducation

Clark County School District    NV
Hillsborough County School District     FL
Dallas ISD      TX
Duval County School District    FL
Memphis City School District    TN
Long Beach Unified      CA
Albuquerque Public Schools      NM
Fort Worth ISD  TX
Mesa Unified District   AZ
Denver County 1 CO
Nashville-Davidson County SD    TN
Santa Ana Unified       CA
El Paso ISD     TX
Tucson Unified District AZ
Columbus Public Schools OH
Arlington ISD   TX
San Antonio ISD TX
San Francisco Unified   CA

There are already 21 districts involved in TUDA -- adding these would bring the total to 39 districts and would give the public and policymakers a much better sense of how big districts are doing in comparison to other, similar systems.  Is it too late to make this an NCLB waiver requirement?  

*Correction:  Three of the 18 districts -- Hillsborough County, Albuquerque, and Dallas -- joined in 2011.  That leaves 15 districts who are eligible to participate but don't.  

Quotes: Duncan Uses MDRC Study To Defend Turnarounds

Quotes2

Much of the conventional wisdom about the impossibility of turning around chronically low-performing high schools is either mistaken or badly exaggerated. - Arne Duncan on MDRC small schools study (via email)

 

Video: Nothing Miraculous About School Improvement

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Online gradebooks, master teachers, weekly PD, credit and attendance recovery -- there's nothing miraculous about what's being done at this Louisiana school profiled in a recent NBC Nightly News segment. Just a lot of hard work, and a willingness to change things up.    

Five Best Blogs: "Race To The Top" Refuses To Die

ScreenHunter_21 Dec. 12 16.38

Race to the Top Likely to Stick Around Politics K12: Race to the Top would be funded in the bill, soon to be introduced. For the first time it would include a district-level competition, sources say. 

January 7: National Opt Out Day teacherken: Posting for your information a message that is being widely distributed among some educational lists and Facebook groups (see image). 

Santorum Concerned Gay Marriage Will Be Taught In Schools HuffPost:  Republican presidential candidate Rick Santorum said he is concerned about legalized gay marriage spilling over into lessons in the classroom, during ...

U.S. school excuses challenged Jay Mathews: The percentage of resilient students in the United States is below the PISA average. Twenty-seven countries, including Mexico, are ahead of us.  

Why Should We Care About Integrating Schools? GOOD (Bill Kurtz): We need to put as many resources into opening high-performing, economically and racially integrated public schools as we do into schools that focus solely on low-income students.

MORE BLOGS INSIDE

Continue reading "Five Best Blogs: "Race To The Top" Refuses To Die" »

Chicago: Is 60 Percent Success Good Enough?

Picture 21Looking back at nearly 100 school closures and turnarounds, the folks at WBEZ Chicago Public Radio and Catalyst Chicago find that roughly 60 percent of the schools brought in to replace or transform low-performing programs are doing OK or better (Level 2 or Level 1 in Chicagospeak) -- but less than 20 percent are at Level 1 and many of those are charters or other special programs.

And so, the issue of whether the replacement schools are at all comparable to the ones they succeeded is the subject of heated debate -- as is the question whether the improvements are big enough or broad-based enough to justify continuing to do turnarounds and replacements and all the upheaval and job churn they entail.  (Like many other cities, Chicago operates under a state testing and rating system that is considered to lack rigor and has been changed several times over the past decade.)

To see the map and the spreadsheet click here.

Context: In-School Use Of Pepper Spray On Students

image from 1.bp.blogspot.comIt's worth remembering that it's not just protesters and bargain-hunters who get pepper-sprayed, and not just traditional law enforcement who's gotten geared up with increasingly fearsome equipment over the past decade. Some of the same things are happening on school campuses, too.  There were a few days during the reporting on my book about Locke High School when I came awfully close to getting myself pepper-sprayed.  One of the key events during 2009, the first year of the turnaround effort involved the use of pepper spray by security guards on a student, and I thought maybe I would get sprayed to see what it was like.  I'd seen the incident firsthand, they spray of liquid and its impact on one of the biggest, most fearsome kids on campus.  And pepper spray had been used during the so-called riot on campus in 2008 witnessed by the LA Times' Howard Blume, and at other high school melees around Los Angeles.  The security guards at Locke sometimes leafed through catalogs full of pepper spray gear -- the things you might have seen riot police holding that look like paintball guns and don't require close contact to be employed.  Have you ever seen kids get sprayed, or come across stories about its use on school campuses?  I'll check around and let you know what I find.  Image via 

Thompson: The Importance Of In-School Suspension

SuspensionPolicyThe Catalyst's Sarah Karp, in her ongoing account of the turnaround of Chicago's Marshall High School, explains how the school is seeking a balance between establishing order and not pushing out/counseling out more difficult students than is necessary.  Karp describes successful in-house suspensions in some schools that allow schools to establish order while providing  counseling.  In one in-house program there was a ten-to-one student teacher ratio, and another had three adults assigned to the program so there was always a person available to counsel students.  Marshall's in-house, despite the praiseworthy efforts of its teacher, has not been successful.  The big problem was the lack of resources, but a seemingly minor detail may explain part of the problem. They banned laughing. If we want to persuade systems to invest in interventions for enforcing codes of conduct, we must prove that the purpose is helping kids, not warehousing them.  The purpose of in-house and alternative programs must be teaching students to be students, not punishment.  These kids must be treated with the same respect we would want for everyone else.  If we would not want a rule banning laughter in an academic class, we should not have one in in-house. - JT (@drjohnthompson)Image via.

Thompson: Turnarounds Serving Fewer Kids, Not More

Catcoverfall2011Sarah Karp of Catalyst Chicago continues an in-depth analysis of the turnaround of Marshall High School.  Nationally, the student population of schools undergoing turnarounds and transformations have declined by 27%, and the shrinkage has been sharper in Chicago.  Marshall, for instance, is competing against twelve new schools, mostly charters.  As a result, only 16% of students in Marshall's attendance area attend their neighborhood high school.  Of course, those numbers cannot be reconciled with the spin that charters and are selective schools are serving "the same students."  Those selective schools serve a disproportionate number of kids who would have been leaders at Marshall, and students who can't meet the academic, behavioral, and attendance standards of new competing schools are free to return to the neighborhood high school.  Marshall's turnaround would probably be impossible if it was not now drawing more of the lines that charters can draw when creating safe and orderly learning cultures.  On the other hand, only 1/6th of the kids in the neighborhood go to Marshall, and only 1/5th of them were counseled out of the school.  Even in our toughest neighborhoods, only a small percentage of students have undergone trauma to the point where they cannot function in a neighborhood school.  If we can afford billions of dollars for turnarounds at scale, we can afford the alternative services necessary to make those turnarounds possible.- JT (@drjohnthompson)Image via.     

SIG: Dumping Money On Bad Schools Doesn't Work (Duh)

image from www.ednewscolorado.org#edcolo @ednews       Here's an EdNews Colorado blog post and podcast of my talk in Denver last week (The “brutal work” of turnarounds), during which I focused on what made the Locke rescue effort unusual (teacher ratification, charter unionization, neighborhood responsibilities) and what Green Dot did that worked and didn't. The Obama initiative to fix the nation's worst schools seems still to be struggling with implementation and capacity issues -- an Obama-created race to the bottom for turnarounds.  As I said during my talk, I don't think you can spend your way to fixing broken schools, or get any sense that the SIG program was designed or has been implemented with any create care. This is work that's too hard to do well for mere money.  There has to be a leader, a group of teachers, or a community organization ready to do the work.  And there has to be someone willing to play bad cop.

Travels: Checking In On Denver's School Reform Movement

image from i.huffpost.com#edcolo @ednews   There wasn't nearly enough time to do everything I wanted to do while I was in Denver -- thanks for all the suggestions! -- but I did get to see some interesting things.  The feature event was a chance to talk about school turnarounds at an event hosted by a bunch of organizations including A+ Denver, Get Smart Schools, Donnell-Kay Foundation, and the Colorado Education Association.  (They know turnarounds here. The attempt to rescue Manual High School was one of the most-watched [New Yorker5280] turnaround efforts of the last decade, the Central Falls of 2007-2008.) Afterwards it was fun to meet and/or hang out a bit with Denver's close-knit school reform mafia (Van Schoales, Mariah Dickson, Rob Stein, Alicia Economos, Tony Lewis, Kristina Tabor, Rob Kellogg, among others).  The next day I got a tour of one of the 3 DSST charter schools, combined middle-high schools that feature a big focus on building community culture and a relatively high degree of student diversity for a charter school.  I also got to see the Lake Middle School turnaround, part of the local district-charter compact that features a district-run IB school sharing a building and doing coordinated recruitment with a charter school (West Denver Prep) that gives priority for neighborhood kids and allows midyear transfers.  And it was great to catch up with Alan Gottlieb and Kristina Tabor to talk about what makes for good education blogging and to hear about all the interesting things going on at EdNews Colorado,  which features in-depth journalism that few other education sites offer.  Anyway, it seems like there's lots going on in Denver.  There's a board election that could alter the current 4-3 alliance that supports the current superintendent.  Former President Bush and his Bush Institute team were in town to talk education.  I should be paying more attention, and perhaps so should you. 

Advertisement

Advertisement

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in This Week In Education are strictly those of the author and do not reflect the opinions or endorsement of Scholastic, Inc.