It's Friday and so I'll be updating the site -- lightly -- via Twitter (which also posts to Facebook and here). See it all below. Have a great weekend! Tweets about "@alexanderrusso"
Vox's Libby Nelson has a good starter list of 12 New Yorker education articles to read while the archives are free but I think she might have missed and/or gotten a few wrong.
No problem -- that's what I'm here for.
It recommends Kate Boo's story about the attempt to revamp Denver's Manual Arts (Expectations) but leaves out her amazing (2006 - I'm cheating) story about early childhood interventions (Swamp Nurse).
Steve Brill's The Rubber Room was an artful rehash of reporting done by others. Rachel Aviv's Wrong Answer is a fascinating look at how some teachers decided they had to cheat that loses out in the end with its lazy reliance on NCLB as the main reason.
Stories mysterious left out include the New Yorker's take on executive function (Delayed Gratification = 210 SAT Points) and Jill Lepore's fascinating revelation that liberal Icon Elizabeth Warren hates neighborhood-based school assignment (Your Favorite Liberal Lawmaker Supports Universal Vouchers*). Nick Lemann's 2010 turning point piece is left out, too (The overblown crisis in American education).
All that being said, kudos to Nelson for getting things started and including some ed-related stories like this summer's Jill Lepore takedown of "innovation" (The Disruption Machine), which I blogged about last month (The Innovation/Disruption "Myth"). Lots more examples from Gawande, Gladwell, etc. to be found. The Hit Man's Tale!?
Previous TWIE posts about the New Yorker: Learning From The Gay Rights Movement; Last Week's Problematic New Yorker Parent Opt-Out Story; The New Yorker Takes Another Look At Coaching; Delayed Gratification = 210 SAT Points; Lessons From Earth Day 1970; If Doctors Can Do It, So Can Teachers, Coaching: Even Veterans & Star Teachers Could Benefit, Checklists: The Simple Solution No One Wants To Try.
Following up on the fascinating topic of the OECD Test for Schools, the PBS NewsHour just recently aired a new segment about the test's spread, how it differs from most annual assessments (and even the Common Core assessments), and some of the reactions of the kids who've been taking it. Transcript here. You can also read all about the test's development and impacts in my recent Harvard Education Letter article. Don't forget that Frontline's segment on resegregation airs tonight.
So you think that edtech (and school reform in general) are full of buzzwords and hot new trends? Well, that may be true. But edtech’s got nothing on adult education, which freely adopts jargon and innovation from the K-12 and postsecondary worlds and then adds its own particular set of terms and approaches.
Some of the developments – flipped, blended, gamified, mobile learning – are familiar trends generally mirroring those taking place in other sectors. Others trends and concepts – contextualization, “braided” funding, and “bridge” programs – are more specific to the needs of low-skill adults and adult education programs who serve them.
No, I'm not going to see the World Cup finals -- just some local travel, friends visiting, and book reading.
See you Monday.
Try not to fix education before I get back; I would be sad to miss that.
Possible mis-application of the semicolon.
Because there's always more to learn, I'm headed off to Chicago to attend the Covering Common Core journalists' training session being hosted by Poynter, EWA, and Northwestern over the next couple of days.
What's your favorite Common Core story so far?
What's a Common Core story you haven't seen, or a bit of knowledge that hasn't been surfaced yet?
Mine include Cory Turner's "taking the Common Core" approach, and my own peek inside the field test help desk, but I'm sure there are other better options.
Alexander Russo's How Waiting for Superman (almost) Changed the World explains how Davis Guggenheim's film created a zeitgeist.
But, did it produce "measurable impact?"
Participant, the film's production company, sought to "ignite social changes." Participant was founded by eBay billionaire Jeff Skoll, and it specializes in "star-laden, carefully crafted, politically colored fims."
Whether Participant knew it or not, in its attempt to claim success, it borrowed from a common school reform meme. Test-driven reformers often claim that increases in student performances in the 1990s were the result of the NCLB Act of 2001. Similarly, Participant claims credit for closing New York City's so-called "Rubber Room," and the Washington D.C. teachers' contract. Both took place before the movie came out.
Michelle Rhee also credits Waiting for Superman for persuading top donors to contribute to StudentsFirst. But, she also claims that her organization is good, not destructive, for public schools.
An objective study, funded by the Ford Foundation, determined that the general public gave good reviews to the film, awarding four out of five stars. Education professionals gave it two stars, concluding that its "depiction of teachers and unions was simplistic."
Russo's account of the making of Guggenheim's film and of its effects is balanced. If he has a bias, it is towards skepticism, even cynicism. Russo indicates that do-gooders must anticipate that their efforts will be "misunderstood or mischaracterized." When that happened, the filmmaker's team responded with "genuine or feigned" surprise.
Before he started Waiting for Superman, non-educator Davis Guggenheim read and reread the definitive but tedious Organizing Schools for Improvement, and went on to study the entire body of work of the Chicago Consortium for School Research. Guggenheim became an expert in economic regression studies so that he could parse the language in papers for and against value-added models. Starting with the work of Larry Cuban, he became an expert on education history.
I kid Guggenheim, of course.
Alexander Russo’s How Waiting For Superman (almost) Changed the World, published by American Enterprise Institute, tells the real story about a pro-union, pro-teacher award-winning filmmaker making a documentary that Jay Mathews described as “one of the most anti-union I had ever seen.”
Russo’s narrative on the making of the film that so deeply offended so many is consistent with my experience. Guggenheim had a lot compassion and he made some political inquiries, but he seemed to have the same disinterest in social science that has long been shown by outsiders seeking to reform schools. It is a testament to the disrespect bestowed on teachers by non-educators that they are consistently uncurious about academic education research. Surely the sponsors of An Inconvenient Truth would not have endorsed that film if Guggenheim was similarly uninformed about global warming.
Worse, Guggenheim and other reformers show even less interest in studying more than one side of the story before pontificating about the cure for inner city educational underperformance.
Only about 5 percent of them are getting anything by way of help with their numeracy, literacy, or English language skills.
Sometimes it's nothing more than a weekly course taught by a volunteeer in the library.
No surprise, then, that adult ed waiting lists are long, and persistence/retention is low.
Rather than thinking about them as a separate population, howver, think about them as your students' parents -- the folks your kids go home to each day, who could help out with schoolwork or not, depending.
That's not the only connection, however.
Read about recent efforts to reboot adult education nationally and locally in my first article for EdSurge (New Urgency Around Adult Education) and you'll see lots that mirrors what's going on in K-12 education -- from the trends (flipped, mobile, gamified, etc.) to the struggle to maintain funding to the widely varying results.
Previous posts: The Story Behind 2010's "Waiting For 'Superman'"; Common Core: A Peek Inside A "Field Test" Help Desk. Image via Skylab Learning.
What's it like working at one of the four Common Core field test help desks that have been set up around the nation to handle calls about the tough new assesments? Check out my latest piece and find out -- then come back here and let us know what you think.
It's Memorial Day Weekend and so I'll be updating the site via Twitter to the extent that I can. Have a great weekend! Tweets about "@alexanderrusso"
Next month, roughly 300 US schools are going to find out how well their sophomores match up to similar students in other countries (and what they really think about the schooling they're receiving). For some of the schools, it will be the second time.
Whether the school-level assessment that provides the scores -- a PISA-based measure called the OECD Test For Schools -- will help schools improve instruction or merely help them market themselves is the subject of my latest Harvard Education Letter piece.
You can find it online here.
Some folks -- Andreas Schleicher, for example -- think it's a great new tool. Others - Pasi Sahlberg -- like the PISA and the OECD Test but worry about schools misusing the results to create rankings rather than revamping their offerings. The handful of schools that participated in the 2012 pilot and talked to me about their scores and responses were a mixed bag.
International testing is coming, one way or the other. And I'm not just talking about IB programs. The Common Core has a lot of overlap with PISA. Three states already get a state-level PISA (as do roughly 100 states and regions in other countries that particpate in PISA). I wouldn't be surprised if more states and districts sign up for the next administrations of PISA and the OECD Test.
Thanks to everyone who helped me with the story -- and not to worry I hope to be writing again about this in the near future so all those conversations and email exchanges won't go to waste. For me, it's fascinating to find out how hungry some educators are for international test results and frustrating if understandable that so many schools participated but haven't revealed their results.
More immediately, there's a ton of information about the experiences and results from Fairfax County (where 10 schools participated in 2012 and 25 participated this year) here. There's also a slideshow from the OECD here.Image via Flickr.
I started getting lots of Tweets and follows on Wednesday and had no idea why until a few helpful folks told me that I'd gotten an unanticipated shout out from a Twitter social media guru during a big webinar about social media.
Dubbed the World's Largest Webinar (#WLW14), the event focused on “The Secrets Behind Social Media” and featured luminaries from Twitter, LinkedIn, and Facebook.
Twitter Senior SMB Russ Laraway told the audience that I (and Michelle Rhee) would be good people to build online relationships with for anyone who wanted to build a quality following on Twitter : "Identify and build relationships with thought leaders and influencers in your industry. For example, if your target audience is educators, you could reach out to Michelle Rhee or Alexander Russo and build relationships with them."
He and I don't know each other. Laraway and his team found me based on Twitter and Google searches and a 2012 TakePart blog post that names me one of the top education Tweeters out there.
Anyway, thanks to Schoolkeep's Ben Wagner (@benwagner23) for filling me in and Laraway for mentioning my name. Little things like this help make up for little indignities like being dumped off the Muckrack top education journalists listing because I don't write frequently enough for mainstream publications.
I started a Tumblr a few years ago to post more images, videos, quotes, and other ephemera related to education that isn't serious enough for here.
I love it but don't worry, nobody else reads it, either.
In honor of one of my most popular posts of all time, a now-defunct annual "beautiful people" roundup, it's called "Hot...For Education."
Recent posts include SF SPED teacher Jeffrey Katz evicted over Airbnb use; Always proofread your hatemail to English teachers; The Survival Selfie; Blackmailed by Your Teacher?; Word Cloud of The Catcher in the Rye.)
In any case, I recently changed the theme (look) so that you can see two posts at a time instead of having to scroll down so far to get to each new post. What do you think? Too much white space, right?
Let me know -- what's a better Tumblr theme to try out? -- or just follow/send me ideas for posts at @hotfored or subscribe here.
Throwback Thursday is a Facebook tradition in which people share pictures of themselves from the past -- usually as kids, teens, or young adults. But nobody really wants to see that stuff from colleagues and counterparts, so I've come up with an adapted version that's a little bit more suitable for a work setting: Throwback Thursday: First Job.
In Throwback Thursday: My First Job, people share images of themselves at their first job -- teacher, counselor, whatever. In my case, my first two important jobs were (a) 7th and 10th grade English teacher at what is now Harvard-Westlake School in LA and (b) legislative aide (education, labor, immigration, health, women's issues) for newly-elected US Senator Dianne Feinstein (D-CA).
A school yearbook picture of me doing the first job (circa 1989) is above. An equally hard-to-believe-I-ever-looked-that-young picture of me working for Feinstein (circa 1995) is below the fold. Take a look, enjoy them both, and then it's your turn. I don't want to find them on my own, but if I have to I will.
Thanks for all the responses to my early April Fool's joke, which seemed to have been enjoyed widely.
Longtime readers will recognize that fake news is nothing new from me (usually tagged "Made-Up News" and presented tongue in cheek). In 2006, I claimed to have found a copy of the reorganization plan being developed for the Chicago Board of Education. In 2o1o, I had Stephen Colbert starting a for-profit chain of K-12 schools to go along with his just-announced Stephen Colbert University. I also announced the creation of a spinoff version of A&E's cable reality show, Intervention, called "Classroom Intervention." In 2011, I made up/predicted the left/right joining of forces against"Obamaschool" (including a joint appearance between Diane Ravitch and Sarah Palin that has yet to happen). I've also had Duncan contracting swine flu, and Spitzer call girl Ashley Dupre as a homeschooled TFA alum.
As always, the motivation is to amuse and provoke insight and skepticism, not to embarrass anyone. Image via Flickr.
It is with *extremely* mixed emotions that I'm announcing that, as of midnight tonight I'm shutting down this site, the related Facebook and Twitter pages, and also my Chicago blog and Tumblr. [Some auto-scheduled tweets from over the weekend may appear in your feed or on your Facebook page, but I officially sent my last tweet last night.]
Wow, that's hard to write. But I'm done. You don't need me doing this every day. I don't need to be doing this every day. It's been a long, amazing ride. I'm really proud of what I've done, and incredibly grateful to have been allowed to do it. Thanks to everyone who's helped make it happen.
What am I going to do instead of blogging? Good question. You see, on a lark this past fall I applied to Teach For America. I told myself it was just for the book I was writing. Nobody was more surprised than I was when I actually made it through and got picked. I had to think long and hard whether or not to quit blogging and accept the spot. But finally I said yes and so I'm going to Houston this summer and starting teaching -- here in Brooklyn, I hope -- in the fall. Wish me luck - I'm going to need it!
Because sometimes the best stuff comes in over the weekend:
Conference of Mayors Urges E-Rate Reform -- THE Journal http://ht.ly/uSuU6
What’s the ‘Sweet Spot’ of Difficulty For Learning? | MindShift http://ht.ly/uSvFN
Obama's view of black culture isn't all that different from Paul Ryan's, says @tanehisi http://ht.ly/uSA0M
The limits of data [journalism] via New Republic http://ht.ly/uSzy0
Oh, no! Matt Damon caught using inaccurate (outdated) child health stats on TV PolitiFact http://ht.ly/uSxAk
From Jay Mathews: Why most people, including me, like homework http://wapo.st/1jrUbne
This past weekend's media panel at the NJ TFA summit included Camika Royal (soon to be at Loyola University in Baltimore), USC's Doug Thomas, free agent (for now) Derrell Bradford, and WSJ metro education reporter (to be) Leslie Brody (pictured above).
The panel included comments from me about the complicated but important process through which most education stories are assigned, written, and massaged before they're published -- and how unrealistic a picture of the education debate you can get from social media (where reform critics rule).
There were also much more useful observations from others: how important it is to find a workspace where you can speak your mind (Royal); teachers are unfortunately reluctant to talk to reporters about what they're seeing even when they're willing to appear in photos (Brody); Twitter is much less constructive and useful than Facebook or other venues where anonymity and unwanted intrusions can be limited (Bradford).
It's over where I and others can post all sorts of images, cartoons (like this harsh NYC charter school example), videos, and GIFs that can't go here (because: copyright).
Next up: All the good stuff on Facebook (it's true!) and Medium.
Image via Flickr.
In case you were curious, here's the "transparency" page for RealClear Education, in which it is explained that the editorial decisions and content that are produced by editors Andy Rotherham and Emmeline Zhao will be independent from not only funders (including the Arnold Foundation, the Hume Foundation, and the New Venture Fund --a sort of clearinghouse / intermediary for foundations) and advertisers but also clients of Bellwether Education (a "growing community of performance-driven education reform leaders, entrepreneurs, organizations, foundations and public institutions").
Check out Tweetails and you can see how much you - or someone you know - is Tweeting.
Apparently I send out about 23 tweets a day (including blog posts), which amounts to 29 hours a month, which makes me a Level 23 Tweet Paladin (and probably a fool).
Lots more details -- word frequency, folks I tweet to/with -- below.
Give it a try and tell me what you found?
News got out this week that Hillel Aron was joining the LA Weekly as a full time staffer. Though he stayed on for a time after my departure from the site at the end of last summer , the workhorse reporter (who did most of the daily writing for LA School Report during its first year of publication) had stopped writing for the education outlet earlier this winter.
So who's left? The masthead there currently includes Jamie Lynton (now listed as Executive Editor), Michael Janofsky (my replacement, as it turned out), and site manager Leigh Anne Abiouness. Vanessa Romo and Chase Neisner have appeared in recent weeks. Ellie Herman has been writing occasional commentaries.
There have been some notable improvements in the site. Someone seems to have finally figured out how to livestream LAUSD board meetings. They've thankfully stopped capitalizing School Board (my fault, if I remember correctly). And they've added links to local news sites from around the sprawling district.
And of course there's always lots of education news to cover in LA. Current examples include the Vergara trial, the ever-contentious school board members, and the never-ending iPad debacle.
As if the protesting teachers and parents and the new CNN documentary weren't enough, here comes my look at Chicago mayor Rahm Emanuel's tumultous first three years at the helm of the city and its beleagured schools system.
The piece (which was originally titled "Reforming Rahm") makes note of just how incremental change had come during the Daley era -- especially the last few years during which a new contract was signed with the union and leadership turnover was the theme -- and what kind of a massive budget and pension deficit Emanuel inherited.
But it also makes clear how Emanuel's rush to take action on things like a longer school day have often backfired, and how he inadvertently helped make a star out of rookie Chicago Teachers Union president Karen Lewis and alienated reform-inclined educators and parents like Seth Lavin as well as "enclave" parents and traditional educators.
Colorful personality conflicts aside, the piece notes that there are still several wortwhile things going on in Chicago, including a move to school-based budgeting, streamlining of testing requirements, a teacher evaluation system to replace the checklist of yore, and a difficult but long-necessary downsizing in response to demographic shifts.
Read the piece -- maybe also Neil Steinberg's recent Esquire profile, too -- and tell me what you think.
The good folks at @ScholasticAdms (who sponsor and host this site!) have rolled out a new feature called Top Five, in which they ask you to weigh in on Twitter with your thoughts about about recent news events.
Use the hashtags to tell us what you think about Duncan's controversial involvement in the recent NYC chancellor selection process (#DODinfluence), schools revamping discipline policies to try and lessen disparities and suspensions(#zerotolerance), the impossibly young innovators who created Edmodo and are scaling up Khan Academy ((#genYleaders), the next Boston superintendent (#urbanleader), and recent science lab explosions (#sciencesafety).
I'm at the EWA seminar on early childhood education today and tomorrow -- great people, great lineup -- and would be tweeting more than posting even if there was WiFi available right now:
Hard to believe that I started the weekly email roundup that became "This Week In Education" in November '03, starting with AOL, then moving to GMail (remember when it was so), then Blogger/Blogspot (your eyes still hurt).
What I'd forgotten along the way is the blog moved over to EdWeek in January '07 -- about six months after I moved to New York City and much later than I had remembered. The Chicago blog moved over to Catalyst and ChicagoNow a little earlier.
Way back then, blogs were still strange and new -- now they're strange and old. Being able to comment immediately rather than write a letter to the editor was new -- now most folks simple Tweet or Facebook what they've got to say.
There was no Politics K-12 or Teacher Beat, no Huffington Post, no Answer Sheet, no GothamSchools/Chalkbeat. Rotherham didn't allow comments. Hess didn't even know what a blog was, much less have his own.
One thing hasn't changed, which is the basic aim of what I'm doing, which I summarized in the 2007 welcome message at EdWeek: "Too often, educators don't understand politics, politicians don't understand education, and education journalists don't understand -- or find ways to capture -- the interactions of these two different worlds. Everyone suffers as a result."
Jacob Riis image via Dana Goldstein's blog.
While you might have been looking the other way, distracted by East Coast media outlets and the like. EdSource Today has quietly been emerging as one of the biggest nonprofit edmedia outlets out there.
They describe themselves as "the leader in California education journalism." They're partnering with other nonprofit outlets like KQED and Hechinger.
Over the past year or two they've staffed up in Northern California (Fensterwald, Baron, Mongeau are the bylines you've been seeing most frequently.) See the staf list here.
Now they're looking to expand in SoCal as well.
Of course, there are other nonprofit education outlets covering California, like the KPCC education shop I've written about before. And a handful of commercial outlets like SI&A Cabinet Report and the LA Times that are still out there. LA School Report has been plugging away, though seems like Hillel Aron isn't writing for them any longer.
Click below for the job announcement. Here's their look ahead at 2014 (Top 12 education issues in the new year).
TED Talks may or may not be the world's most intellectually rigorous form of idea-sharing for adults, as several recent blog posts and articles have suggested, but the format -- in full or just parts of it -- still has some appeal and potential benefits for teachers and students who want to try it out in schools.
This new Harvard Education Letter story I wrote explores schools' small but growing use of TED Talks. Classroom and in-school uses of TED Talks are turning into whole-school TEDx events and even (in at least one case) whole-district TED Talks
"Hosting a standalone TEDx event is no easy feat. For student organizers, the event requires the ability to organize and coordinate, to think through logistics and ideas, and to work with adults as well as other students... Organizers' duties include finding speakers and a venue that's appropriate, creating a program and TEDx event logo, deciding which TED Talks to play in between live presentations, scripting and shaping presentations, recruiting an audience, and arranging with teachers and administrators for students to attend. TEDx events are supposed to be filmed from three different angles, streamed live online, and uploaded to the Internet. (The head-mounted microphone, use of buzzwords, and dramatic pauses are optional.)"
I'm off to Boston for the holidays so you'll have to make do without me for a few days -- I'm sure you'll be OK. Check EdWeek or GothamSchools or Politico's Morning Education or the Annenberg Institute for a news roundup. I'm sure one or several of them will help you out. Meantime, all the best, safe travels, and thanks as always for checking this site out. [Image via Superb Wallpapers]
My latest Scholastic Administrator column is out, focusing on how the NCLB implementation and pushback history compares to the Common Core process we're going through now (Whither CCSS?).
"At the time, a number of states considered opting out. Several states (including Connecticut, Arizona, Utah, and Nebraska) and districts filed lawsuits against NCLB. So did the NEA and 11 districts scattered around the nation. Others sought accommodations, proposed legislation, or reported on the costs of complying with the new law. Three wealthy Connecticut districts opted out of the program entirely in 2003, followed by two districts near Chicago."
Back to the present: A few more states have slowed down their CCSS participation since the piece was written -- I think we're up to seven now, right? -- but the basic argument remains the same.
"If the history of NCLB is any guide, the vast majority of the current efforts to reconsider or roll back the Common Core will lose steam or result in some relatively minor accommodation well short of opting out. Whether that is a good thing or not depends on where you stand."
The annual Spencer Education Journalism Fellowship luncheon took place a couple of weeks ago and those alumni in attendance made up a veritable who's who of education reporting. They included Liz Bowie (Balt Sun), Greg Toppo (USA Today), Dana Goldstein (Slate, Nation), Sarah Garland (Hechinger), Trey Kay (NPR). Those not able to make it -- Sarah Carr, Peg Tyre, Elizabeth Green, among others -- are an equally impressive lot. (That's the 2010 crew pictured right.)
Latest Spencer news: Greg Toppo just got a book contract for his learning games book and is joining the Spencer advisory board. Dana Goldstein just turned in her completed manuscript. Sarah Garland has a very cute baby. Current Spencers Jamaal Abdul-Alim, Lauren Smith Camera, and Annie Murphy Paul were all there, too.
All this to say that the Spencer Fellowship is up again for 2014-2015 and if you think you have the stuff to make it through Evidence and Inference and Sam Freedman's book writing workshop you should apply. Seriously.Your idea is great. You're totally qualified. The competition isn't too tough. (Plus which, the Nieman deadline is already passed.)
See the latest press release below. Don't forget.
Check those sites for updates, or go to GothamSchools or AISR or HuffPost Education or Atlantic Education for a morning news roundup. Or Politics K12, or Politico's Morning Read.
Have a great day, and see you back here Monday!
Over at the Atlantic's education page, check out my top education stories of the year and let me know if you agree or disagree. There's something for everyone. Or, try and guess my 9 and see how many you get right. I'm going with #ed2013 but that's probably already been used or won't take off. Image via the Atlantic.
Social media isn't anything new, and TWIE has been on Facebook and Twitter long before many other sites. But as a few of you have noticed, there haven't been social media buttons on the site itself -- until now.
All that's changed now. Look below. Look above. All around you, Twitter and Facebook buttons so you can "like" and Tweet out individual blog posts without fuss or muss -- thanks to Wayne D'Orio and the eScholastic folks who pulled it off.
Thanks, and enjoy! Let me know if you have any issues.
Alexander Russo's Atlantic Magazine article, When Parents Yank Their Kids Out of Standardized Tests, begins with photographs of the signage that has become so ubiquitous in schools. As the seemingly endless testing season begins, learning stops in schools full of posters stating, "Testing in Progress" and "Lab Is Closed."
The article explains how teachers at Seattle’s Garfield High School refused to give the district’s required tests and encountered the predictable pushback and quotes a Garfield teacher who anticipates “the biggest revolt against standardized testing in U.S. history” during this spring's three month long testing season. [He also cites the Brookings Institution’s Tom Loveless who recalls that parent protests against tests “pop up like wildfires” about every decade.]
I'm proud that that parents in Oklahoma are also helping to lead the backlash. Russo cites the case of Jenks Middle School where 800 parents opted out of last spring's piloting of test questions. He quotes Deedra Barnes, who helped organize the boycott, and who is considering an opt out for the high-stakes testing in 2014. Testing, she says, is out of balance.
So far, at least, Secretary of Education Arne Duncan has decided to insult suburban moms rather than listen to them, but he's not alone. DFER's Charlie Barone “just doesn’t see the groundswell of opposition against testing that FairTest and others claim to exist.”
But how would they? What actual contact with real schools do Duncan and Barone have? Of course, there is far too much testing. As Diane Ravitch said to comedian John Stewart, "The status quo today is test, test, test, pretest, posttest, data.” The only way to deny the anger felt by parents, teachers, and students is to hypothesize that we are all suffering from a mass hallucination.
The magazine also links to a previous article by a teacher, Ben Orlin, When Memorization Gets in the Way of Learning. Orlin describes the destructive rote learning and cramming encouraged high-stakes testing. It is a reminder that as testing forces teachers to engage in more and more educational malpractice, the backlash is bound to grow.
-JT(@drjohnthompson) Image via.
My new piece is just up over at the Atlantic education page, describing the spate of recent parent opt-outs.
Clearly, opt-outs and other forms of protest are on the rise to some extent, and have already had effects in a handful of places. But anecdotal reports don't mean that everybody hates testing (and even those who protest do so for very different reasons).
Teachers' concerns re tests being used for evaluations shouldn't be confused with parents' concerns about lost classroom time, for example.
My biggest frustration reporting the story is that while there are lots of anecdotal reports of what seems like test proliferation there's no one I could find who's tracking the number of tests that states and districts are requiring so that we can see if the trend is up and if so how widespread it is. A little help, someone?
Just as frustrating, there's no accurate count of the percentage of parents who opt-out that districts, states, or anyone else is reporting -- though The Nation reports that the New York protests last spring amounted to just 1 percent of all parents. Again, some reliable numbers would be useful.
Thanks to experts like Bob Schaeffer, Anya Kamenetz, Tom Loveless, Charlie Barone, Michael Lomax, and the folks at Achieve and USDE for talking to me about the trend dynamics, as well as parents and teachers like Jesse Hagopian, Peggy Robertson, Liz Dwyer, Chris Thiennes, Rebecca Labowitz, and Deedra Barnes for talking to me about their opt-out experiences and everyone else who helped or offered to -- as well as Eleanor Barkhan and Julia Ryan for the helpful edits. Apologies to folks I didn't get to talk to (or whose best lines got left on the cutting room floor).
Previous posts: Either you’re against the Common Core or you’ve never heard of it; The Moral Complexities of Opting Out (Thompson).
It also might be worthwhile to ponder the day's meaning for education.
At first glance, there's not much connection between education and veterans. But look below the surface and there connections start to emerge:
There are veterans all around schools these days -- classroom teachers, administrators, clerical and classified staff, and of course parents.
There have been various "Troops to Teachers" kinds of programs for recent and long-ago veterans -- though I've heard mixed things.
Veterans can also be found in central offices -- sometimes even leading school districts (it was very popular to hire military veterans to head school systems).
I haven't yet many veterans among the current school reform movement leaders, or among the leaders of those who are opposed to these efforts.
Who'm I missing?
The two main theories behind the last few days of tumult and rumor in LA are (a) that Deasy authorized a leak to scare the board into keeping him (and it nearly got out of hand) or (b) that Deasy opponents (most likely Mike Trujillo in Richard Vladovic's office) leaked the story to try and create momentum around an early Deasy departure.
So which was it and why didn't the leak work?
There was an amusing exchange at about the 40 minute mark of the Hess / Knowles / Duncan Common Core confab yesterday in Chicago (pictured above left).
Coming onstage to join Knowles and Duncan, Hess expressed feigned unease at appearing with Knowles, who was named one of education's hottest advocates in 2005 (pictured above right).
Knowles' response? "You can see what happens in eight or ten years, right?"
For the record, Hess was also suggested for Hot For Ed '05, but blogger Joanne Jacobs rejected the idea: "I've seen Rick Hess, and he's no Tim Knowles."
Click here for some local coverage or watch the video below. I promised you a video, after all.
Love the Common Core #CCSS or hate them (or somewhere in between), you gotta love David Coleman's colorful socks in the image accompanying the digital edition of my recent interview with him in Administrator Magazine (which sponsors this site):
There are also lots of other great images from the magazine, which I'm taking the liberty of posting here just for the fun of it, along with the full image of Coleman.
I'm taking the long weekend and will be back on Tuesday.
Of course, there have been and will be a few Tweets if you are really desperate (or compulsive, as I am).
Everyone else is working, I'm sure -- so check your other blogs, too.
See you Tuesday AM!
Image via Scholastic Administrator.
So it's been a few days now since the Atlantic education page launched, and while others may have been paying closer attention (tell me!) I feel like I'm beginning to get the sense of what it's going to be all about (at least for now).
So far, at least, it's basically shaping up to be an all-education version of the site's National page, which has has long carried education reporting from EWA's Emily Richmond (What Makes a Great Teacher: Training? Experience? Intelligence? Grit?) and Hechinger. For a long list of posts I've written about or with Atlantic.com material in the past, click here.
Remember that school in the works a couple of years ago in New Orleans, where the goal was to take some of the best elements of private progressive and structured charter schools and make a diverse environment?
Its founder, Josh Denson, spoke at the time about how frustrated he was with the dominant (90/90/90) charter school model, and yet “In schools where it’s all about learning, discovery, and projects and teamwork, there seems to me to be an absence of or a reluctance to have any kind of accountability.”
Well, the school, Bricolage, opened this year. It's goals are to "launch a new kind of school - one that advances educational equity and creates innovators who change the world." I wrote about it in my November 2012 Education Next piece, Diverse Charter Schools.
Meantime, the USDE has apparently pressured another set of folks trying to explore the diverse charter schools idea against setting up a lottery preference based on ELL status.
As reported in GothamSchools (Facing federal funding freeze, Success to nix lottery preference), the Success network has been told to give up its ELL priority or lose charter school startup funding.
Other diverse charters, including Brooklyn Prospect and Community Roots, might not face such pressures since they're not replicating startups, but it's still a bad signal to send to schools trying to do something interesting and potentially very powerful (ie, find a sweet spot between charters and district schools). Brooklyn Prospect has now grown into the high school years, as originally envisioned, and also is opening an elementary school starting with kindergarten this year.
According to the GothamSchools article, other charters with preferences for single-parent kids, autistic kids, and other priorities could soon be affected. Ironically, the USDE ruling on the lottery issue will indirectly encourage/allow charters to serve larger percentages of white/affluent families.
I'm checking around to see if other schools in NY or other states are being affected.
So far, at least, Bricolage hasn't needed a weighted lottery. The first class's demographics are roughly 45 percent free lunch, slightly lower than the application and lottery yields.
Here are some of the big stories in the latest ("back to school" edition of Scholastic Administrator (@scholasticadms), the magazine that sponsors this blog (and runs a regular interview and column from me as well):
President Poses for E-Rate: Obama introduces E-Rate upgrade program, ConnectED. The goal? To bring high-speed Internet access to every school in the U.S.
The Future of a Shuttered School: School closures are on the rise, but what if student enrollment rebounds?
The Fantastic Five: Profiles of leaders who initiated radical, and successful, changes.
Are Tablets Better Than Laptops? Top educators debate which device fits students best.
Charlotte's Turnaround Artist: Ann Blakeney Clark: Ann Blakeney Clark on working with under-performing schools, strategic staffing and collaborating with fellow educators.
Is Your School Assessing Security? A look at which measures offer the best protection at a time of ever-shrinking budge
If you want to see the whole magazine in all its electronic glory, go here.
In my absence, follow @gtoppo at USA Today (he's even better on Facebook), or see if there's anything good at #reformy (my favorite word and little-used hashtag), or check out @gothamschools' morning roundup.
Have a great Labor Day weekend, and see you back here bright and early on Tuesday.
Candidate credibility matters to voters. Newspaper endorsements *can* make a real difference. Campaign money isn't magic. Internal polling can be *very* misleading. Absentee ballots and walking precincts matter.
To read the whole thing, cruise on over: Lessons from L.A.
Then come back here and disagree (or agree) with me.
Image via Scholastic.